Brilliant Knowledge and Decodo are two main proxy suppliers with comparable infrastructure and have units, placing them on comparatively equal footing. Decodo earned our Editors’ Selection award for small and medium-sized companies, whereas Brilliant Knowledge—although not an Editors’ Selection winner—stands out with an enormous pool of 150 million residential proxies, making it a robust choice for enterprise customers. Each providers maintain a four-star ranking and a spot on our listing of the perfect proxies, however just one comes out forward on this comparability. Beneath, I break down their key variations, evaluating infrastructure, belief, privateness, and general worth.
Value: Decodo Delivers Higher Worth at Each Tier
Brilliant Knowledge has plans extra suited towards companies reasonably than people. You’ll be able to’t pay anonymously with cryptocurrency, both. Devoted IPs begin at $22 per thirty days for 10 proxies and go as much as $1,300 per thirty days for 1,000 proxies. Shared IPs might be had for much less with a $14-per-month plan for 10 proxies because the baseline, and $900 per thirty days for 1,000 proxies as the utmost tier. ISP proxies begin at $18 per thirty days for 10 shared IPs and $35 for 10 devoted IPs. There’s additionally a pay-as-you-go plan for $15 per GB. Brilliant Knowledge additionally gives cell proxies at $8.40 per GB, or you may pay for knowledge in bulk in case you plan to make use of a variety of bandwidth. Residential proxies additionally begin at $8.40 per GB, with that very same bulk buy knowledge deal accessible.
Decodo accepts cryptocurrency and gives a bit extra flexibility with smaller baseline plans for people. Datacenter proxies begin at $5.55 per thirty days for 3 IPs and vary as much as $2,300 per thirty days for two,000 IPs. Static residential proxies begin at $9.99 per thirty days for 3 IPs and go as much as $4,000 per thirty days for two,000 IPs. Decodo gives cell proxies that begin at $15 per thirty days for 2GB of information and cap out at $550 per thirty days for 100GB. Residential proxies have a decrease asking worth than Brilliant Knowledge’s at $3.50 per gigabyte. Month-to-month plans vary from $6 for 2GB to $225 for 100GB.
There are all the time a variety of choices in relation to configuring a proxy, which makes it troublesome to return to a definitive worth comparability. Typically, I discover that Decodo gives a greater worth proposition whereas additionally accepting a wider vary of fee strategies. Nonetheless, Brilliant Knowledge nonetheless has loads of aggressive proxy sorts relying in your use case and what number of you propose to purchase.
Winner: Decodo
App Design: Decodo’s Dashboard Feels Extra Trendy and Intuitive
Whereas some components of proxy dashboard layouts are subjective, I do my finest to maintain the evaluations on this part as goal as potential.
Brilliant Knowledge encompasses a white-and-blue-themed dashboard with easy left-hand navigation tabs and proxy stats within the middle. It’s the form of dashboard that will get the job executed with none further frills or daring design selections. There aren’t any obvious omissions or poorly designed options, but it surely doesn’t stand out a lot from the competitors.
(Credit score: Brilliant Knowledge/PCMag)
Decodo’s dashboard feels extra skilled with a black, grey, and purple design. Buttons are a bit bigger. There are extra interactive components and bins. Proxies are damaged into small subsections on the primary dashboard, making it straightforward to flip between with out getting misplaced.
(Credit score: Decodo/PCMag)
Each proxies have serviceable dashboards, however Decodo put a bit extra effort into it. It has a extra skilled really feel and was simpler to navigate general.
Winner: Decodo
Get Our Finest Tales!
All of the Newest Tech, Examined by Our Consultants
Join the Lab Report to obtain PCMag’s newest product opinions, shopping for recommendation, and insights.
Join the Lab Report to obtain PCMag’s newest product opinions, shopping for recommendation, and insights.
By clicking Signal Me Up, you affirm you might be 16+ and comply with our Phrases of Use and Privateness
Coverage.
Thanks for signing up!
Your subscription has been confirmed. Regulate your inbox!
Proxy Pool: Brilliant Knowledge Leads With Sheer Scale
Most proxy websites don’t publish actual figures as a result of the scale of every firm’s proxy pool fluctuates continuously. Nonetheless, each Decodo and Brilliant Knowledge present basic figures that give a tough thought of what to anticipate.
Brilliant Knowledge:
Datacenter proxies: Greater than 770,000 IP addresses
Residential proxies: Greater than 150 million IPs in 195 areas
Cellular proxies: Greater than 7 million cell IPs in 160 areas
Decodo:
Really useful by Our Editors
Datacenter proxies: Greater than 500,000 devoted and shared proxies (400,000 of these being primarily based in the US)
Residential proxies: Greater than 115 million IPs accessible in 195 areas
Cellular proxies: Greater than 10 million cell IPs in 160 areas
It’s a detailed name, however Brilliant Knowledge edges out the competitors in each datacenter and residential proxy protection. Decodo continues to be a wonderful selection, particularly for cell proxies, however Brilliant Knowledge comes out forward on this class.
Winner: Brilliant Knowledge
Privateness and Person Knowledge: Decodo Has an Edge on Knowledge Practices
Brilliant Knowledge complies with the European Union’s GDPR and California’s CCPA insurance policies. Nonetheless, that solely means the corporate shops knowledge in compliance with rules, not that it doesn’t gather person knowledge in any respect. The truth is, Brilliant Knowledge collects fairly a bit of information, together with publicly accessible knowledge that you just or your online business could not have ever given the corporate entry to. Brilliant Knowledge seems to scrape the net for knowledge resembling your full title, e-mail tackle, tackle, web site interactions, job historical past, geolocation, and extra. The corporate could be very clear about what it collects, however that doesn’t change the truth that Brilliant Knowledge hoards a big quantity of person knowledge.
Decodo does gather some person knowledge, which is pretty normal for proxies. The corporate claims it doesn’t monitor person visitors requests, but in addition states that it’s going to detect and block customers for unlawful or morally questionable actions. Figuring out data, resembling fee particulars and e-mail correspondence, is saved. How lengthy Decodo retains knowledge varies relying on the kind of knowledge and the corporate’s use for it. Decodo defines this as “just for a period that’s fairly mandatory for pre-defined functions,” which implies it might be indefinite. For residential proxies, Decodo claims to supply each proxy ethically, with knowledgeable consent.
Winner: Decodo
And The Winner Is…
Brilliant Knowledge and Decodo have related function units and infrastructure, however Decodo pulls forward in nearly each key space. It gives extra aggressive pricing, an easier-to-use app, and a stronger privateness coverage. It’s barely behind Brilliant Knowledge when it comes to datacenter and residential proxies, however its spectacular cell proxy community nearly ranges the enjoying subject. Total, it’s a detailed matchup between these four-star proxy providers, however Decodo will get the win for its higher worth proposition and extra user-friendly knowledge insurance policies.
