PC Journal’s unique mission assertion, again in 1982, did not contain the wide-ranging tech protection we do at this time. Our inaugural situation bore the tagline “The Impartial Information to the IBM Private Laptop.” Apple merchandise did not match the invoice, however the firm was finally too massive a presence within the computing world to disregard.
As early as our July 23, 1985 situation, the print journal featured a 23-page evaluation titled “IBM vs. Apple: Is Mac Prepared for Enterprise?” We debated the utility of Apple’s early printers and continuously referenced main Apple merchandise that predated our founding, such because the Apple II, which launched almost 5 years earlier than our first situation.
Over the a long time, Apple stopped being the area of interest outsider, and our personal scope expanded to embody telephones, tablets, companies, and extra. We have been there for the corporate’s industry-defining highs and the inventory price-plummeting lows. With the latest profitable launch of the MacBook Neo, it’s clear this story remains to be being written.
So, to have a good time Apple’s fiftieth birthday, we went digging by the archives for a few of the greatest and worst Apple merchandise we have reviewed or in any other case written about. Listed below are a few of the many Apple gadgets—each wins and failures—we have lined through the years.
Apple II (1977)
(Credit score: PCMag)
We did not really evaluate the Apple II, because it got here out a couple of years earlier than PC Journal‘s print debut, but it surely nonetheless had a spot on our pages, even once we have been completely overlaying IBM-compatible desktops. Even that first situation (February-March 1982) included an op-ed from editor Jim Edlin (a self-described Apple-to-PC convert), a full article in regards to the resale worth of previous Apple II methods, and an interview with Invoice Gates during which he talked about the Apple II as a benchmark for the nascent {industry}.
LaserWriter (1985)
(Credit score: PCMag)
Again when printers have been our bread and butter—PC Journal devoted entire points to printer testing and critiques, making us an authority within the rising house—we reviewed the Apple LaserWriter, a high-quality laser printer in an period when dot-matrix printers have been nonetheless massive.
Although the printer was bought for an eye-watering $6,995, it featured built-in AppleTalk help and may very well be shared throughout a community of as much as 16 customers, giving it an efficient per-user price of underneath $450. Paired with some wonderful phrase processing software program (Aldus PageMaker) and early WYSIWYG modifying, it proved revolutionary. By offering professional-grade typography, accessible software program, and options that made it pleasant to small enterprise, the LaserWriter helped usher within the desktop publishing growth.
However the massive factor for our editors? It additionally labored with Adobe PostScript and will hook up with a PC through serial port. In keeping with reviewer Chris Petzold in our September 1985 situation, “the LaserWriter may give you a few of the best-looking Occasions New Roman and Helvetica fonts you’ve got ever seen from a laser printer or every other pc printer.” It apparently was the primary Apple product to obtain a PCMag Editors’ Alternative award.
Mac Moveable (1989)
(Credit score: PCMag)
When PCs began going transportable, we have been there. As a part of a large testing roundup of 73 portables (starting from suitcase-like luggables to notebook-esque early clamshell designs) within the March 1990 situation of PC Journal, we reviewed the Apple Macintosh Moveable. It had a 600-by-400 monochrome, non-backlit active-matrix LCD that was “exhausting to learn in low lighting.” It additionally boasted a 16MHz 68HC000 processor with 1MB of RAM, a selection of trackball or a 10-key numpad, a 3.5-inch floppy drive, an SCSI port, two serial ports, and weighed almost 16 kilos. Not unhealthy for a machine powered by lead-acid batteries.
“Technically, the Macintosh Moveable is spectacular,” wrote Frederic E. Davis, then the director of PC Labs. “However its value, weight, costly RAM, and nonbacklit display screen are all important drawbacks.”
And it bought for $6,500—or no less than, the primary items did. Gross sales did not break 10,000 within the first quarter of launch, and Apple began discounting it by $1,000 or extra earlier than the yr was out. It was an authorized flop for Apple, but it surely did pave the best way for one thing nice: The Apple PowerBook.
PowerBook (1991)
(Credit score: PCMag)
In 1991, the Apple PowerBook took a distinct path. Designed in collaboration with Sony, it set the template for early laptop computer ideas with a clamshell design, a pointing machine within the palmrest, and a keyboard moved again nearer to the display screen and the hinge.
When reviewer Lori Grunin reviewed the PowerBook 170 in our August 1992 situation, she famous that the laptop computer “incorporates most of the world’s greatest elements.” With a bigger show, a slimmer and lighter design, and higher battery administration, the PowerBook was a shock industrial hit, producing over $1 billion in its first yr.
“After the disappointingly overpriced and outsized Mac Moveable,” Grunin wrote, “it is no marvel that many Mac customers have gone cellular with the PowerBook 170 and PowerBook 140 (6.8 kilos every) and the 5.1-pound PowerBook 100.”
“With costs beginning at $1,599 for the PowerBook 100,” Grunin added, “it seems to be like Apple has efficiently impressed one other case of Mac envy.”
Newton MessagePad (1993)
(Credit score: PCMag)
Lengthy earlier than the iPhone or the iPad, there was the Newton. The Apple Newton MessagePad was a top-of-the-line private digital assistant (PDA). Along with cool options like a stylus, handwriting recognition, and gesture controls, it additionally used an ARM 610 RISC processor, marking Apple’s first foray into the ARM platform and away from the usual desktop OS, paving the best way for future main improvements.
We did not give anybody an Editors’ Alternative award in October of 1993, as a result of we declared the PDA class “too immature” for an award. Evaluating the Newton to different pen-based PDAs, reviewers Christopher Barr and Michael Neubarth wrote, “Though the Newton’s handwriting recognition engine is the most effective we have seen—it interprets cursive writing and printing, or any mixture of the 2—it stays removed from excellent.”
Whereas it pioneered the thought of the post-PC machine, its reliance on short-lived AAA batteries, lack of included desktop connectivity, and $699 beginning value made it a tricky promote. In 1998, the product line was discontinued.
Pippin (1996)
(Credit score: Evan Amos/Public Area)
Bear in mind when Apple made a recreation console? That is OK, nearly no person does. In 1996, Apple was attempting to make a standalone recreation system constructed on Mac OS and utilizing the PowerPC processors utilized in Mac methods. However it was additionally a play for licensing and partnerships, with Bandai serving to to design the outer casing for Apple’s internals, and different corporations lined as much as make Pippin packing containers for Japan, Canada, and the US markets.
We did not really evaluate the machine, however we did speak about how excited we have been for the Pippin as a Web-terminal to hook up with the TV. Senior editor Sebastian Rupley wrote in February 1996, “With the corporate’s sub-$1,000 Pippin system, you’ll browse the Net utilizing your TV and a handheld controller.”
However the Pippin by no means made a lot of an affect. It launched towards machines just like the Sony PlayStation and Sega Saturn, and in early 1997, manufacturing was halted attributable to poor gross sales; unsold items have been shipped again to Japan, the place no less than a couple of folks had purchased them.
iMac G3 (1998)
(Credit score: PCMag)
Shortly after Steve Jobs’s return to Apple, he tapped Jony Ive to design the Apple iMac, a daring new all-in-one PC. The beautiful teardrop design, translucent plastic development that showcased the inner elements, and the spectacular ease of setup grabbed the eye of the PC {industry}. The intense-colored desktop turned heads within the PC Labs, too—the truth is, we nonetheless have one kicking across the workplace purely for nostalgia’s sake!
In our 1998 First Take a look at the iMac, we praised the straightforward setup, the spectacular (if small) show, and needed to clarify the shortage of a floppy disk drive. However the true head scratcher was the inclusion of a newfangled USB port, which changed the SCSI/ADB mixture used on prior Macs.
In 1998, the machine was a finalist for the Technical Excellence awards, and by the point the iMac DV Particular Version got here out in 1999 (this time in a cool translucent graphite grey shade), we included it in a roundup of the most effective PCs for Each Price range, highlighting it as an amazing selection for low-end video modifying, even when we thought of the efficiency lackluster.
In our second take a look at the machine, in January 1999, editors Tom Pope and Nick Stam felt compelled to level out how a lot we might appreciated it the primary time round: “We thought the iMac regarded excellent the primary time. Now that it has been in use for a few months—in workplace settings in addition to houses—with no important issues and with extra peripherals accessible to fill the gaps left by its design, we contemplate the iMac to be one of many standout pc merchandise of the yr.”
iMac ‘Puck’ Mouse (1998)
(Credit score: iCreate Journal/Future through Getty Photographs)
Regardless of the iMac’s success, one peripheral stood out like a sore thumb: the hockey puck mouse.
The spherical mouse that got here with the iMac acquired combined critiques. The translucent plastic development gave customers a glimpse of the circuit board and trackball inside, which was cool, and the color-matched design was an amazing visible counterpart to the trendy iMac, however really utilizing the factor was awful.
The spherical form wasn’t ergonomically excellent, the USB cable was too brief, and the one mouse button wasn’t clearly marked, resulting in some person confusion. We by no means devoted a full evaluate to the mouse, however as editor Tom Pope famous in our 1998 First Look with the iMac, “It is spherical, so by chance pointing it within the mistaken path is simple.”
Energy Mac G4 Dice (2000)
(Credit score: PCMag)
Sizzling on the heels of the iMac got here the Energy Mac G4 Dice, a desktop with an much more bold design. This was a mini PC earlier than the class even existed, an 8-inch dice encased in clear acrylic that ran silently and not using a fan. It is arguably a design masterpiece—it was a finalist within the design class of our Technical Excellence Awards in 2000—but it surely flopped exhausting.
The design was beautiful, however divisive. The Dice was positioned between the consumer-friendly iMac and the professional-grade Energy Mac G4 desktop tower, however lacked a transparent market.
Get Our Finest Tales!
Your Each day Dose of Our High Tech Information
Join our What’s New Now publication to obtain the most recent information, greatest new merchandise, and knowledgeable recommendation from the editors of PCMag.
Join our What’s New Now publication to obtain the most recent information, greatest new merchandise, and knowledgeable recommendation from the editors of PCMag.
By clicking Signal Me Up, you affirm you might be 16+ and conform to our Phrases of Use and Privateness
Coverage.
Thanks for signing up!
Your subscription has been confirmed. Keep watch over your inbox!
Gross sales fell far wanting expectations, and the acrylic enclosure confirmed seen mould strains that some mistook for cracks, additional affecting gross sales. However the true blow for this design darling was the worth. At $1,799, it was costlier than the G4 tower however lacked enlargement choices and was deemed too premium for many patrons.
iPhone (2007)
(Credit score: PCMag)
The primary iPhone wasn’t excellent, but it surely was undoubtedly successful. The contact display screen, the media capabilities, the straightforward syncing with Mac or PC—it was a transparent win. However our evaluate additionally identified that it had crummy name high quality, awful enterprise e-mail, and a digital keyboard that wasn’t as intuitive as later variations.
As reviewers Sascha Segan and Tim Gideon mentioned of their 2007 evaluate, “Once you boil it down, the Apple iPhone is an iPod with Web, YouTube, lovely graphics, a digital camera, and an enormous display screen—and oh yeah, it might additionally make calls and verify e-mail.”
However this is the kicker: “When Apple ultimately releases an iPod with all these options besides the cellphone, it’s going to blow away the competitors. Because it stands proper now, the iPhone is a really wonderful (and costly) toy.”
What can we are saying? Not each success seems to be nice while you first encounter it. Nonetheless, we gave it 4 stars. The truth is, in our December 4, 2007 situation, we highlighted Steve Jobs within the Technical Excellence Awards as Particular person of the 12 months/Innovator, particularly calling out “the Apple iPhone, which lifted the cellular phone’s interface out of the darkish ages and into the twenty first century.”
MacBook Air (2008)
(Credit score: PCMag)
When the MacBook Air was launched in 2008, it was touted because the thinnest laptop computer ever. The three-pound laptop computer was lighter and slimmer, however lasted solely three hours in battery exams. It wasn’t only a resounding success; it outlined the ultraportable laptop computer for the subsequent couple of a long time.
Laptop computer lead analyst Cisco Cheng praised the design and the full-size show, however wasn’t impressed by the restricted port choice and the battery, which wasn’t user-upgradable. We gave it 3.5 stars, saying, “Although the MacBook Air positively has some shortcomings, it’s hands-down the thinnest and prettiest laptop computer on the market.” And ultimately, that was all it wanted to alter the {industry}.
It wasn’t the primary or solely ultraportable—we did a roundup of 5 ultraportables the very subsequent month (Could 2008), together with the Air—however the MacBook Air received the glamor shot for the article. And, if we’re sincere, it has been the poster baby for the ultraportable class ever since.
Magic Mouse (2009)
(Credit score: Apple)
Finally, Apple found out easy methods to make an amazing mouse. It simply took till 2009, with the Magic Mouse, which mixed a low-profile wi-fi mouse with capacitive contact expertise, rendering the acquainted mouse in a buttonless glass kind. After we reviewed it in 2009, we cherished the glossy, minimalist design and the “magic” of multitouch gestures, reminiscent of two-fingered swipes and fast switching between right- and left-handed modes. The sharp, exact laser sensor and seamless Bluetooth pairing have been further standout options.
Our evaluate says that the Magic Mouse can “do methods no different mouse can, and it is simply essentially the most engaging enter machine you may discover.” One other unambiguous success for Apple. However it wasn’t excellent—it was powered by two non-rechargeable AA batteries, placing a damper on the entire wi-fi angle—and the subsequent replace would repair one downside however solely introduce a brand new one: a charging port on the underside of the mouse that renders the Magic Mouse 2 unusable whereas charging. Even after Apple up to date the Magic Mouse 2 with a brand new port (switching from Lightning to USB-C), it frustratingly stored the bottom-side charging port.
Really useful by Our Editors
iPad (2010)
(Credit score: Apple)
When the primary iPad arrived, folks clowned on the title, mocked the shortage of multitasking, and complained about different options that weren’t current, together with a front-facing digital camera. However proper from the beginning, our reviewer, Tim Gideon, knew it might “undoubtedly be a driving pressure in shaping the rising pill panorama.”
Our 4.5-star evaluate highlighted the glossy design, touch-screen accuracy, and app choice. Positive, it lacked Flash help, a digital camera, multitasking, and did not include earbuds or a case/cowl, but it surely set the bar excessive.
iPhone 5 (2012)
(Credit score: PCMag)
The sixth iteration of Apple smartphones, following the iPhone 4s, was the primary iPhone developed fully with out Steve Jobs’s oversight. With a thinner, lighter, aluminum design and an even bigger, higher show, it wasn’t simply an impressive 4.5-star Editors’ Alternative product. It was additionally one in all our Better of the 12 months merchandise for 2012.
As our reviewer Sascha Segan wrote on the time, “With a elegant, however acquainted design inside and outside, a speedy new processor, quick LTE, and the most effective apps within the enterprise, the brand new iPhone is just like the previous iPhone, simply significantly better.”
Apple Maps (2012)
(Credit score: Apple)
Oh, Apple Maps. You had the entire iPhone set up base as your probability to indicate up Google for navigation. And also you flubbed it. After we reviewed the app in 2013, it was riddled with inaccuracies, lacked real-time visitors data, and skilled frequent glitches. It was sufficient that the app, whereas secure to make use of whereas driving, simply could not prime Google Maps. All of this was compounded by a scarcity of map information.
Apple Maps has improved significantly in its decade-plus of existence, however Google Maps remains to be the clear chief.
Mac Professional (2013)
(Credit score: Apple)
A working theme for Apple is a bent to prioritize conceptual design over primary performance. Certainly, the corporate’s greatest flubs most relate to this type of aesthetic overreaching. However even when a product has issues, it might garner reward. The cylindrical Mac Professional from 2013 is the proper instance of this.
I reviewed this quirky desktop again when it was new and praised it for its “dramatic departure from boring, boxy designs.” Positive, it regarded a bit like a rubbish can, but it surely delivered category-leading efficiency in benchmark exams, had some spectacular options—like Thunderbolt connectivity and a slick inner design—all whereas staying whisper-quiet. Regardless that I had misgivings, I gave it an Editors’ Alternative award.
However that stovepipe design did not really deal with warmth in addition to we thought, and the shortage of inner enlargement turned off many consumers—even when the present Mac Studio nonetheless depends on the same all-Thunderbolt method to enlargement and added performance. However Apple not solely deserted the design, it principally gave a point-by-point counterargument to its personal advertising when it introduced the return of the tower-style with the 2019 Mac Professional.
Butterfly Keyboard (2015)
(Credit score: Apple)
It is somewhat bizarre to look again on the short-lived Apple MacBook in gentle of the drastically cheaper and extra consumer-friendly MacBook Neo—each 12-inch MacBooks that sit outdoors of the extra premium MacBook Air and MacBook Professional mannequin strains. However the greatest failure of that individual product wasn’t the laptop computer itself, however a particular characteristic that additionally confirmed up on the costlier Mac laptops.
The Butterfly Keyboard was launched in 2015, and its keyboard-switch design was highlighted as a vital a part of Apple’s MacBook’s slim, transportable design. It was additionally the supply of main shopper complaints: the brand new change brought about the keyboard to malfunction if even a trivial quantity of mud received into the mechanism, and customers reported lacking inputs, repeated inputs, and uneven or sticky-feeling keys.
In our preliminary evaluate of the 12-inch MacBook, we complained, “New keyboard and Power Contact trackpad take some getting used to.” It wasn’t the one factor holding again that product, but it surely was arguably a failure greater than anyone product. It received so unhealthy that Apple provided free repairs to anybody with any of the merchandise that featured it, together with the MacBook, MacBook Air, and MacBook Professional fashions from 2015. And in 2018, the corporate confronted a category‑motion lawsuit that led to a settlement paying Apple prospects as a lot as $395 over the bum switches.
AirPods (2016)
(Credit score: PCMag)
AirPods might seem like simply one other pair of Bluetooth headphones to most, however in 2016 they modified the sport. With the AirPods, Apple succeeded in making wi-fi headphones that simply work, and added options that also exceed what most non-Apple opponents provide.
In our evaluate, Tim Gideon wrote, “The Apple AirPods really feel like a giant step for wi-fi in-ear audio—but it surely’s extra about improvements and options and fewer about audio efficiency.” Whereas subsequent variations would enhance particular options, the primary entry within the product line was a strong success, with hundreds of thousands of gross sales making it Apple’s hottest accent. Because the evaluate mentioned, “Apple will get so many issues proper that different producers wrestle with.”
Apple M-Collection (2020)
(Credit score: Apple)
Technically, Apple Silicon has been a factor for the reason that A4 chip debuted within the first iPad. However it was the leap to placing Apple’s personal chips into the Mac lineup that cemented Apple Silicon as a large success. In 2020, the M1 chip provided dramatic enhancements in performance-per-watt, delivering full-power efficiency whereas lasting for hours on a battery. The fanless model within the MacBook Air (2020) and Mac Mini (2020) allowed for near-silent operation and gave Apple seamless integration between {hardware} and software program.
Throughout the board, reviewers hailed the M1 as a generational leap ahead for PC efficiency and longevity, and that has solely continued as Apple has up to date the M-Collection yr after yr.
MacBook Neo (2026)
(Credit score: Joseph Maldonado)
The brand new MacBook Neo is shaping as much as be a large vendor, with an ultra-low value to go together with its ultraportable design and stripped-down characteristic set. Powered by an Apple A18 Professional iPhone chip and that includes essentially the most repairable design in MacBooks, this MacBook delivers an amazing finances laptop computer with out the standard compromises that low-cost Home windows laptops or Chromebooks have lengthy pressured folks to just accept.
We aren’t certain it is a success but, because it’s solely been in the marketplace for the previous couple of weeks, however, as editor Joe Osborne wrote in our evaluate, “Apple really pulled it off, a 100% new, no-nonsense 13-inch MacBook for $600.” That is a outstanding achievement at a time when different tech merchandise are getting costlier, and the finances laptop computer house is contracting somewhat than rising.
About Our Skilled
Brian Westover
Principal Author, {Hardware}
Expertise
From the laptops in your desk to satellites in house and AI that appears to be all over the place, I cowl many matters at PCMag. I’ve lined PCs and expertise merchandise for over 15 years at PCMag and different publications, amongst them Tom’s Information, Laptop computer Magazine, and TWICE. As a {hardware} reviewer, I’ve dealt with dozens of MacBooks, 2-in-1 laptops, Chromebooks, and the most recent AI PCs. Because the resident Starlink knowledgeable, I’ve finished years of hands-on testing with the satellite tv for pc service. I additionally discover essentially the most priceless methods to make use of the most recent AI instruments and options in our Strive AI column.
Learn Full Bio
