I’ve used noise-cancelling headphones for years, and I all the time observed the identical unusual sensation. Each time I turned ANC on, it felt like my ears have been filling with strain — like being on a aircraft mid-descent or diving deeper underwater.
I assumed that was how ANC labored for everybody; a barely pressured feeling that, whereas not uncomfortable, I might undoubtedly do with out.
It seems I used to be mistaken. That feeling of strain is not regular, and most significantly, it’s not one thing it’s a must to put up with.
ANC would not really create, however it could actually really feel prefer it does
My poor little ears
The sensation of strain from ANC is pretty frequent. It even has its personal, considerably odd-sounding identify: eardrum suck. I can not consider many issues worse than that, however we’re sadly going to must reside with it. Or, as you will see, we do not, however we all know that phrase exists.
Anyway, let’s clear up the most important false impression first: lively noise cancellation doesn’t bodily change the air strain inside your ears.
So why does it really feel like strain once I placed on sure pairs of ANC headphones and earbuds?
The reply is your mind. It depends closely on low-frequency sound to grasp your environment, like distant site visitors, air motion, or the hum of a room. When ANC wipes these out, your mind immediately loses these reference factors.
The result’s a bizarre sensory mismatch. Nothing bodily has modified, however your mind interprets the silence as strain or imbalance.
It is a comparable expertise in case you’ve ever been anyplace unsettlingly quiet, like an anechoic chamber (a chamber designed to soak up sound). The few instances I’ve stepped into one in every of these chambers, I spotted that silence actually can drive you loopy. I’ve added a video beneath displaying how lengthy folks can stand these silent chambers for — it is by no means lengthy!
The true trigger is low-frequency cancellation
Eardrum suck for everybody
Credit score: Christine Persaud / MUO
ANC is only at cancelling low-frequency, fixed sounds — precisely the form of noise your mind makes use of to construct a way of house. Consider issues like engine rumble, air-con, or distant background noise. These sounds are a core a part of how your ears keep oriented in an atmosphere and make it easier to place your self.
So, while you expertise a whole absence of these sounds, your auditory system doesn’t fairly know what to do with itself. For some of us, like me, that may flip into the sensation that your ears are being pushed inwards, which is the place the “below strain” feeling comes from.
The large distinction is that some folks by no means discover. It is not one thing that impacts everybody, and much more, sensitivity varies relying on a variety of components. So, in case your ears are extra tuned to these low-frequency cues, you’re way more more likely to really feel the impact.
As well as, ANC waveform matching can glitch and finally find yourself by accident amplifying sure frequencies as an alternative of canceling them out, resulting in a sense of strain.
A 2019 SoundStage!Solo interview explains this phenomenon extra eloquently than I might hope to, however the gist of it’s that ANC techniques intentionally restrict how a lot cancellation they apply at increased frequencies. The result’s an uneven sound profile: sturdy cancellation within the bass, petering out rapidly as frequencies rise.
That imbalance is what creates the feeling. Your mind immediately loses these low-frequency cues it depends on for spatial consciousness, whereas higher-frequency sounds stay partially intact. The sharper the transition between these two areas — what engineers name the filter slope — the extra noticeable the impact turns into.
In brief, the extra aggressive the ANC, the extra seemingly you might be to really feel eardrum strain.
Associated
I am going to Solely Purchase Headphones From These 8 Manufacturers
In terms of headphones, these are my go-to manufacturers for audio high quality, consolation, and extra.
Why some ANC headphones really feel worse than others
Not all ANC is created equal
The standard of ANC varies massively between gadgets. That is why some headphones and earbuds have superb ANC, whereas others are principally pointless. This has an actual affect on how a lot “strain” your ears really feel.
Some headphones, particularly cheaper fashions, apply very aggressive noise cancellation with much less refined tuning. That may strip away an excessive amount of environmental sound, making the impact really feel unnatural and even disorienting.
Match additionally performs an enormous function. Over-ear headphones are inclined to create a stronger seal round your ears, which may amplify the feeling. In the meantime, earbuds can fluctuate wildly relying on the ear tip measurement and the way tightly they sit in your ear canal.
In my case, I observed the impact way more on sure pairs than others, regardless that all of them had ANC enabled. Stronger cancellation doesn’t all the time imply higher — it typically simply means extra noticeable unintended effects.
The settings that mounted ANC ear strain
Eardrum suck be gone
There are literally a few methods you possibly can repair the sensation of ANC ear strain.
The primary, and by far the simplest, is to only modify your headphones. In some circumstances, placing my headphones on slowly and permitting the air strain to slowly equalize really made a distinction (regardless of it not being an air strain downside, actually).
Typically, placing the headphones on, letting them get cozy, then lifting the underside or aspect of the cup helps alleviate the ANC ear strain downside, too.
There are ANC settings that may repair ANC strain, too. I sometimes use ANC cranked as much as the utmost, however realised that once I’m at residence in my workplace, with the children in school, and it is simply the cats and me, I do not want it at most. Turning down the ANC or switching to Adaptive ANC nearly instantly lowered the sensation of ANC ear strain and stored it that means.
The issue
The repair
What it fixes / why it really works
ANC feels too intense or “overbearing”
Swap from full ANC to adaptive ANC
Adaptive modes let some environmental sound by way of, particularly low frequencies, which helps your mind retain spatial consciousness and reduces that synthetic “vacuum” sensation
Stress feeling is strongest in quiet environments
Use transparency/ambient mode indoors
In quiet areas, ANC has little or no to cancel, so it could actually really feel unnatural. Letting in a small quantity of real-world sound restores steadiness and removes the feeling
Your ears really feel fatigued after lengthy listening classes
Take brief breaks from ANC
Your auditory system can turn into overstimulated by fixed cancellation. Even a couple of minutes with out ANC helps your mind “reset”
The impact feels worse with sure earbuds
Attempt completely different ear suggestions or a looser match
A tighter seal will increase isolation, which may exaggerate the strain sensation. Adjusting the match reduces that closed-off feeling
Over-ear headphones really feel extra uncomfortable than anticipated
Barely reposition the ear cups
Small shifts in positioning can change how sound waves work together along with your ear, lowering the depth of low-frequency cancellation
The feeling varies wildly between headphones
Decrease ANC power within the app (if out there)
Some headphones permit fine-tuning of ANC ranges. Lowering depth retains noise discount whereas avoiding overly aggressive cancellation
You don’t must attempt all of those directly, both. In my expertise, simply switching ANC modes or barely adjusting the match was sufficient to utterly take away that “strain” feeling.
Associated
I Didn’t Notice My AirPods May Do This—Now I Use Them In another way
Your AirPods can achieve this way more than you initially thought.
ANC strain may not be actual, however you continue to really feel it
And that is why you want these fixes
That “strain” feeling from ANC isn’t actual in a bodily sense, however the discomfort completely is.
The excellent news is that fixing it doesn’t require new headphones or difficult tweaks. Usually, it’s only a matter of adjusting how your ANC works, not whether or not it’s on or off.
When you discover it, it’s laborious to disregard. However with the best settings, it’s simply as simple to do away with and maintain all the advantages of noise cancellation with out the downsides.
8/10
Battery Life
As much as 135 hours
Microphones
3
Model
Nothing
Transducer Measurement
40mm
